Background
Malaria remains a public health problem in Mauritania with an estimated of 250,000 clinical cases reported annually
1
. Data reported during the two last decades shown an increase in malaria cases from 26.933 in 1990 to 188.025 in 2006
2
. The majority of infection is due to Plasmodium falciparum, which is responsible for more than 80% of malaria cases and entomological studies show that the main vector is Anopheles gambiae
1
3
4
5
6
7
. Throughout the country malaria is endemic with a seasonal transmission from July to October, as is the case in the most Sahelian countries
1
8
. The country can be divided into three epidemiological strata: the Saharan region in the north, representing 80% of the country’s area with annual rainfall less than 100 mm, where malaria transmission is rare. A sero-epidemiological study conducted in 1980s showed prevalence between 8 and 15% of history of infection with P. falciparum in this zone
9
. In the Sahelian zone, located in the southern part, between Nouakchott and Nema (annual rainfall 100-300 mm), malaria is unstable and seasonal transmission during rainy season can cause deadly epidemics
3
4
. The Sudanian region in the South, bordering with the Senegal River Valley (annual rainfall 300-600 mm), an agricultural area, including rice, where malaria transmission is stable, but with a significant difference in prevalence between the rainy season and the dry season
1
. Despite the enormous efforts that have been directed toward malaria control and prevention
10
, multiple factors including insecticide resistance in anopheline vectors, the lack of effective vaccines, and the emergence and rapid spread of drug-resistant strains are the major problems for controlling and preventing malaria.
Therefore, the development of an effective malaria vaccine continues to be urgently needed. However, extensive genetic diversity in natural malaria parasite populations is a major obstacle for the development of an effective vaccine against these parasites, because antigenic diversity limits the efficiency of acquired protective immunity to malaria
11
12
. Many P. falciparum proteins have been proposed for use as vaccine candidate antigens, but the merozoite surface protein-1 (MSP-1) has been most studied
13
14
. Extensive genetic polymorphism of the msp-1 gene has been identified in P. falciparum isolates worldwide
15
16
17
. It is important to investigate the diversity of msp-1 gene, in different geographic areas for the further development of effective malaria vaccine. The gene coding the merozoite surface protein 1 (msp-1) has been widely used as a marker for genotyping parasite populations
18
19
20
. In P. falciparum, the surface protein MSP-1 (around 190 kDa) plays an important role in erythrocyte invasion by the merozoite
21
. The protein is a principal target of human immune responses
22
and is a promising candidate for a blood stage subunit vaccine
14
23
. The msp-1 gene occurs as one of three distinct allelic families: K1, MAD20 and Ro33
24
. It has 7 variable blocks that are separated either by conserved or semi-conserved regions. Block 2, a region near the N-terminal of MSP-1, is the most polymorphic part of the antigen and appears to be under the strongest diversifying selection within natural populations
21
.
The genetic diversity of P. falciparum has been extensively studied in various parts of the world, but limited data are available from Mauritania. The only study on P. falciparum population genetic structure using msp-1, msp-2 and glurp markers date back 15 years
4
. The present study examined and compared the genetic diversity of P. falciparum isolates among febrile patients attending health facilities in Nouakchott and Hodh El Gharbi region in Mauritania, during the peak of malaria transmission, using the polymorphic gene encoding for the merozoite surface protein-1 (MSP-1).
Methods
Study sites
The study was conducted in Hodh El Gharbi (HG), south-east Mauritania, and in Nouakchott, the capital city of Mauritania during the rainy season in September–October 2010 (Figure 1). HG region (latitude 16° 13′ 02″ N, longitude 9° 54′ 44″ W) covers a surface area of 53,000 km2 with four departments, (Aïon, Kobeni, Tintane and Tamchekett). The population of HG is approximately 212,156 inhabitants
25
. Most residents are subsistence animal breeders and farmers. The climate in HG region is Sahelian characterized by a long dry season, lasting from October to June, and a rainy season extending from July to September. It receives between 200-300 mm of annual rainfall. The monthly mean temperature ranges from 24 to 37°C. A transmauritanian highway of 1,200 km from Nouakchott to Nema in the far south-eastern region of the country passes through HG from west to east. HG region can also be reached on a paved road from Nioro du Sahel in Mali. The region is poorly served by health service facilities. There is only one hospital in Aïoun and one health centre in each department. Nouakchott (18°.11′N; 16°.16′W), is situated in a Saharan zone, near the Atlantic coast at an average altitude of 7 m. It comprises nine districts and houses 743,511 inhabitants corresponding to one fourth of the whole population of the country
25
. The wet season is short, extending from July to September, with little annual variation in the amount of rainfall (50-80 mm). The monthly mean temperatures in Nouakchott varied from 21°C to 30.5°C. Nouakchott is served by five hospitals and nine health centres spread across the city. HG and Nouakchott exhibit every year high level of human migration with Nouakchott residents traveling and staying in Hodh El Gharbi during the months of July, August, September corresponding to the school vacations, and returning to Nouakchott in October and November.
<p>Figure 1</p>Map of Mauritania showing the study sites
Map of Mauritania showing the study sites.
![]()
Patients and blood samples collection
The samples of this study were collected from 676 febrile patients attending Kobeni, Tintane and Aïoun health faciltities in HG region and the 'Centre Hospitalier National’, 'Centre Hospitalier Cheikh Zayed’ and 'Centre de Santé de Teyarett’ in Nouakchott. Before blood sample collection, informed consent was obtained from all participants or in case of children from their parents/legal guardians prior to their enrolment. The study was approved by 'the Direction Régionale de l’Action Sanitaire, DRAS, under the authority of the Mauritanian Ministry of Health.
During the study, if patient presented to health facilities with symptoms consistent with mild malaria, including fever, chills, headache, and a positive slide, they were offered standard ACT as first-line treatment. Among the patients enrolled, 276 (40.8%) were microscopically confirmed as P. falciparum infection. Out of these 114 (40.7%) patients were from Kobeni, 89(31.7%) from Tintane and 55(19.6%) from Aïoun in HG region and 18(6.5%) patients from Nouakchott. A total of 113 patients were randomly selected from the 276 P. falciparum positives patients by microscopy. A finger prick blood sample was taken from each consenting patient for thick and thin blood film and 2-3 drops were collected on Whatman® No. 3 filter paper, dried and stored in individual plastic bag until used for DNA extraction.
Malaria parasite identification
Thick and thin smears were stained with Giemsa. Parasite density was determined by counting the number of asexual parasites per 200 white blood cells, and calculated per microlitre using the following formula: number of parasites x 8,000/200, assuming a white blood cell count of 8,000 cells per μl
26
. Absence of malaria parasites in 200 high power ocular fields of the thick film was considered as negative. Obtained data were graded according to parasitaemia: 1, patients with 50-499 parasites/μl; 2, patients with 500-4,999 parasites/μl; 3, patients with more than 5,000 parasites/μl.
Plasmodium falciparum DNA extraction
Parasite DNA was extracted, from blood samples blotted on filter paper by methanol method described by Djimde et al.
27
. Briefly, 500 μl of methanol was added to a 1.5 ml microcentrifuge tube containing three or four pieces of filter paper and incubated at 15 min at room temperature. The methanol was poured off and the papers heated at 95-100°C in 50-70 μl of sterile distilled water for 15 minutes of incubation, during which the tube was gently vortexed every five minutes. The samples were centrifuged twice and the final supernatant was stored at -20°C until used for the amplification reaction. All PCR analyses were conducted in the 'Service de Parasitologie’ at the Faculty of Medicine, Université Cheikh Anta Diop, Dakar.
PCR amplification of the P. falciparum msp-1 gene
The highly polymorphic locus, msp-1 block 2, was used for the genotyping of the P. falciparum population using the nested polymerase chain reactions (PCR) technique. The msp -1 primers sequences used in this study are shown in Table 1
28
. For the primary amplifications (outer PCR), primer pairs corresponding to the flanking sequence of the conserved regions of msp -1 was used (Table 1). The second amplification reactions (nested PCR) were based on the primary products using allelic-specific primers sets corresponding to K1, RO33 and Mad20 families of msp-1. The primers for msp -1 used in this study are shown in Table 1. All outer and nested PCR reactions were done in 25 μl final volume. For each reaction, 200 μM each of deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate (dNTP), 1 μM of each primer, 0.5U of Taq DNA polymerase and PCR Buffer 10X containing 100 mM Tris–HCl, pH 8.3, 500 mM KCl, 15 mM MgCl2 and 0.01% gelatin were used. The outer and the nested amplification were performed on an Applied Biosystem 2720 and PTC-100 Peltier Thermal Cycler respectively using the following conditions: initial denaturation for 3 min at 94°C, followed by 30 cycles of 25 s denaturation at 94°C, 35 s annealing at 50°C, and 2 min 30 extension at 68°C. Final extension was carried out at 72°C for 3 min. Nested PCR products were visualized by electrophoresis on 2% agarose gel (Gibco-BRL) for various lengths of time depending of the predicted size of the PCR products and visualized under UV trans-illumination.
<p>Table 1</p>
Sequences of oligonucleotide primers used to genotype
msp-1
block 2 allelic types of
Plasmodium falciparum
isolates from Mauritania
Amplification/Primer
Sequence
Polymorphism
Outer PCR
Msp1F
5′AAGCCTTAGAAGATGCAGTATTGAC3′
Conserved
Msp1R
5′ATTCATTAATTTCTTCATATCCATTATC3′
Nested PCR
K1F
5′AAGAAATTACTACAAAAGGTG3′
K1 family specific
K1R
5′TGCATCAGCTGGAGGGCTTGCACCAC3′
K1 family specific
Ro33F
5′AGGATTTGCAGCACCTGGAGATCT3′
Ro33 family specific
Ro33R
5′GAGCAAATACTCAAGTTGTTGCA3′
Ro33 family specific
Mad20F
5′TGAATTATCTGAAGGATTTGTACGTC3′
Mad20 family specific
Mad20R
5′GAACAAGTCGAACAGCTGTTA3′
Mad20 family specific
Allelic distribution and multiplicity of infection
The msp-1 alleles were categorized by their molecular weights and considered the same if their molecular weights were approximately within 10 bp
29
. The multiplicity of infection (MOI), or complexity of infection, was estimated by the average number of PCR fragments per infected individual, as described by Zwetyenga et al.
30
.
Statistical analyses
Statistical analyses were performed using MedCalc for Windows, version 12.3.0.0 (MedCalc Software, Mariakerke, Belgium). Proportions were compared for significance using the χ2-test. Spearman’s rank correlation coefficients were calculated to assess associations between multiplicity of infection, parasite densities and age groups of patients under study. A P value of ≤ 0.05 was considered indicative of a statistically significant difference.
Results
Characteristics of the study population
Out of the 113 randomly selected P. falciparum patients attending health facilities in study sites, 31.8% (36/113) were from Kobeni, 34.5% (39/113) from Tintane, 17.7% (20/113) from Aïoun and 16% (18/113) from Nouakchott (Table 2). Males (70/113; 61.9%) were significantly higher (χ2 = 6.4; p = 0.01) than females (43/113; 38.1%). Patients belonging to the age group 5-19 years were the most represented with 55.8% (63/113) followed by those of 20-39 years of ages with 28.3% (32/113), patients whose ages ≥ 40 years with 12.4% (14/113) and children under five years representing 3.5% (4/113).
<p>Table 2</p>
Population characteristics of
P. falciparum
infected patients from different study sites in Mauritania
Characteristics
Kobeni
Tintane
Aïoun
Nouakchott
Total
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n: number of individuals.
Gender
Male
20(55.6)
27(69.2)
12(6)
11(61.1)
70(61.9)
Female
16(44.4)
12(30.8)
8(4)
7(38.9)
43(38.1)
Age group
< 5
1(2.8)
1(2.56)
2(10.0)
0
4(3.5)
5-19
21(58.3)
23(59.0)
13(65.0)
6(33.3)
63(55.8)
20-39
13(36.1)
7(17.95)
4(20.0)
8(44.5)
32(28.3)
≥ 40
1(2.8)
8(20.5)
1(5.0)
4(22.2)
14(12.4)
Total
36(31.8)
39(34.5)
20(17.7)
18(16.0)
113(100)
Allelic polymorphism of msp-1
Allele typing revealed highly polymorphic nature of Mauritanian P. falciparum isolates with respect to msp-1 gene. K1, Mad20 and Ro33 MSP1 allele’s types were identified. The total number of different sized alleles detected in this sample was 27. Among them, nine for K1 (160-400 bp), 12 for Mad20 (140-400 bp) and six for Ro33 (160-360 bp) allele families were noted. Frequencies of different msp-1 alleles and their combinations and multiplicity of infection are shown in Table 3. The frequency of samples with only K1, Mad20 and Ro33 were 10.6% (12/113), 2.6% (3/113) and 4,4% (5/113) respectively. K1/Mad20, K1/Ro33 and Mad20/Ro33 combinations were found in 21.2% (24/113), 16.8% (19/113) and 2.6% (3/113) of samples respectively and 41.6% (47/113) of them harbored all three allelic types. Prevalence of K1, Mad20 and Ro33 allelic types was 90.0% (102/113), 68.1% (76/113) and 65.5% (74/252) respectively. Multiple clones infections over all study sites was 82.3% (93/113) with a minimum of 72.2% (13/18) in Nouakchott and a maximum of 90.0% (18/20) in Aïoun. Multiplicity of infection (MOI) was highest in P. falciparum infected patients enrolled in Aïoun health facility (4.3 genotypes per infection) and lowest in those from Nouakchott health facilities (2.3; mean of three health facilities). However, obtained MOI values were not statistically different from each other (p = 0.56). The estimated MOI of all studied area was 3.2 genotypes per infection.
<p>Table 3</p>
Msp-1
block 2 allelic type frequencies and multiplicity of infection of
P. falciparum
isolates from different study sites in Mauritania
Allelic type
Kobeni
Tintane
Aïoun
Nouakchott
Total
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n: number of individuals; MOI: multiplicity of infection.
K1
4(11.1)
6(15.4)
1(5.0)
1(5.5)
12(10.6)
Mad20
1(2.8)
0
1(5.0)
1(5.5)
3(2.6)
Ro33
0
2(5.1)
0
3(16.7)
5(4.4)
K1/Mad20
7(19.4)
10(25.6)
6(30.0)
1(5.5)
24(21.2)
K1/Ro33
9(25.0)
4(10.2)
0
6(32.3)
19(16.8)
Mad20/Ro33
2(5.5)
0
0
1(5.5)
3(2.6)
K1/Mad20/Ro33
13(36.1)
17(43.6)
12(60.0)
5(27.8)
47(41.6)
Total
36(100.0)
39(100.0)
20(100.0)
18(100.0)
113(100.0)
Total K1
33(91.6)
37(94.9)
19(90.0)
13(72.2)
102(90.0)
Total Mad20
23(63.8)
27(69.2)
19(90.0)
7(38.8)
77(68.1)
Total Ro33
24(66.6)
23(58.9)
12(60.0)
15(83.3)
74(65.5)
Multiclonal isolates
31(86.1)
31(79.5)
18(90.0)
13(72.2)
93(82.3)
MOI
3.1
3.2
4.3
2.3
3.2
Relationship between multiplicity of infection, age groups and parasite densities
Age group distribution of P. falciparum-infected patients and msp-1 block 2 allelic types is shown in Table 4. The prevalence of K1, Mad20, Ro33 and their different combinations was significantly higher among patient aged 5-19 years compared to other age groups (p < 0.05) (Table 4). However, no significant correlation between multiplicity of infections and age groups of patients (Spearman rank coefficient = 0.2; p = 0.8) was noted. The distribution of K1, Mad20 and Ro33 according to parasitaemia is shown in Table 5. This study found that the individual distribution of K1, Mad20, Ro33 was not significantly different among parasitaemic groups (p = 0.94). Multiclonal isolates was not significantly different neither between 50-499 parasites/μl and ≥ 5000 parasites/μl (p = 0.09), or between 50-499 parasites/μl and 500-4999 parasites/μl (p = 0.08). However, estimated parasitaemia and multiplicity of P. falciparum infection was significantly correlated (Spearman rank coefficient = 1; p < 0.01).
<p>Table 4</p>
Distribution of
P. falciparum
msp-1 block 2 allelic type among age groups of
P. falciparum
infected patients from Mauritania
Age group (years)
Allelic type
< 5
5-19
20-39
≥40
Total
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n (%)
n: number of individuals; MOI: multiplicity of infection.
K1
1(0.9)
8(7.1)
1(0.9)
2(1.8)
12(10.6)
Mad20
0
1(0.9)
2(1.8)
0
3(2.6)
Ro33
0
2(1.8)
2(1.8)
1(0.9)
5(4.4)
K1/Mad20
1(0.9)
17(15.0)
6(5.3)
0
24(23.0)
K1/Ro33
1(0.9)
10(8.8)
6(5.3)
2(1.8)
19(16.8)
Mad20/Ro33
0
2(1.8)
1(0.9)
0
3(2.6)
K1/Mad20/Ro33
1(0.9)
23(20.3)
14(12.4)
9(7.9)
47(41.6)
Total
4(3.5)
63(55.7)
32(28.4)
14(12.4)
113(100.0)
Total K1
4(100.0)
58(92.1)
27(84.3)
13(92.8)
102(90.3)
Total Mad20
2(50.0)
43(68.2)
23(71.8)
9(64.3)
77(68.1)
Total Ro33
2(50.0)
37(58.7)
23(71.8)
12(85.7)
74(65.5)
Multiclonal isolates
3(2.6)
52(46.0)
27(23.9)
11(9.7)
93(82.3)
MOI
3.25
3.21
3.03
3.37
3.2
<p>Table 5</p>
Distribution of Msp-1 block 2 allelic types among parasitaemic groups of
P. falciparum
infected patients from Mauritania
Allelic type
Parasitaemia*
50-499 n (%)
500-4999 n (%)
≥5000 n (%)
Total
(*) parasite/μl of blood; n: number of individuals; MOI: multiplicity of infection.
K1
1(0.9)
6(5.3)
5(4.4)
12(10.6)
Mad20
1(0.9)
2(1.8)
0
3(3.5)
Ro33
0
2(1.8)
3(2.6)
5(4.4)
K1/Mad20
1(0.9)
10(8.8)
13(11.5)
24(21.2)
K1/Ro33
6(5.3)
9(7.9)
4(3.5)
19(16.8)
Mad20/Ro33
0
1(0.9)
2(1.8)
3(2.6)
K1/Mad20/Ro33
2(1.8)
22(19.5)
23(20.3)
47(41.6)
Total
11(9.7)
52(46.0)
50(44.3)
113(100.0)
Total K1
10(90.9)
47(90.4)
45(90.0)
102(90.3)
Total Mad20
4(36.4)
35(67.3)
38(76.0)
77(68.1)
Total Ro33
8(72.7)
34(65.4)
42(84.0)
74(65.5)
Multiclonal isolates
9(7.9)
42(37.2)
42(37.2)
93(82.3)
MOI
2.6
3.4
3.6
3.2
Discussion
This study was undertaken to assess the polymorphism of the merozoite surface protein-1 block 2 allelic types in P. falciparum isolates from different study sites in Mauritania. Plasmodium falciparum is thought to be responsible of nearly 80% of diagnosed malaria cases in the country
1
. A better understanding of population structure of P. falciparum genotypes may be an important element for implementing malaria control strategies in the country. Data showed a relatively high polymorphic nature of K1, Mad20 and Ro33 msp-1 allelic types according to the number of band sizes (27 different PCR products: 9 K1, 12 Mad20 and 6 Ro33) among Mauritanian P. falciparum isolates. Comparable results were found by Jordan et al.
4
; authors noted 11, 8 and 2 different sized alleles respectively for K1, Mad20 and Ro33 in P. faliparum isolates from malaria patients in Aïoun and Kobeni area located in southern Mauritania. The number of different msp-1 alleles observed among P. falciparum isolates is also comparable to that founded by Konate et al.
31
in the holoendemic area of Dielmo (Senegal) where 33 msp-1 alleles were evidenced, but less than that reported by Soulama et al.
29
who founded 41 different sized alleles for msp-1 block 2 region in P. falciparum isolates collected from children with uncomplicated malaria infection living in Burkina Faso. The study also revealed the predominance of K1 type alleles either at study site level or throughout the parasite population compared to Mad20 and Ro33. Similar finding have previously reported among P. falciparum isolates from Aïoun and Kobeni
4
. In Dakar, P. falciparum isolates from 48 Senegalese patients hospitalized for malaria showed a prevalence of 68% for K1 alleles
32
. Most of the isolates were mixed infections (82.3%) which harbored more than one allele type. However, prevalence of patients with multiclonal infection was similar in all study sites. A relatively high multiplicity of infections (MOI) was observed among P. falciparum patients either at study site level (2.33-4.25) or over all the study sites (3.22) reflecting the high intensity level of malaria transmission during the study period. When they compared 63 P. falciparum positve samples taken from febrile patients in Aïoun and 110 positive samples from Kobeni, Jordan et al.
4
reported a multiple infections of 1.57 and 2.34, respectively. It is reported that the multiplicity of infection in an infected patient may be due to an important entomological inoculation rate as shown in the Senegal village of Dielmo where patients receive a large number of infective bites
31
, or by a single mosquito carrying several parasitic clones in his inoculums
33
. In the context of the present study, it is difficult to speculate on the influence of mosquito inoculum on the multiplicity of infection because no such data is available for the study sites in Mauritania. The MOI values reported in this study are consistent with those reported from regions with high malaria endemicities
34
. Furthermore, there was no association between MOI and age of patients. Investigations conducted in Senegal (Ndiop village where malaria is mesoendemic and seasonal) and Benin (Cotonou), founded that MOI was not affected by age of malaria patients
31
35
. Previous studies regarding the variation of MOI over age have suggested that the influence of age on the multiplicity of infection is highly affected by endemicity of malaria which is probably a reflection of the development of anti-parasite specific immunity
36
. However, this finding contrasting with reports from other locations
29
31
37
. A positive correlation between multiplicity of infection and parasite densities was observed in this study (MOI = 2.6-3.6). This is consistent with many reports demonstrating that higher parasite densities increase the probability of detecting concurrent clones in an individual
18
38
. This study used P. falciparum isolates from patients with clinical symptoms, so that the MOI may be lower than that reported in asymptomatic patients
39
. Many reports showed that MOI would reflect that infected individual has immunity against malaria
31
. Thus, the MOI should be studied in asymptomatic P. falciparum-infected population in Mauritania further, particularly in children. The similarity between P. falciparum strains could be explained by population migration between study sites that may allow for exchanges of parasite population. Similar results were noted in many malaria endemic areas
40
41
42
. The present study is the second report based on molecular epidemiology of P. falciparum following the work conducted by Jordan et al.
4
in Aïoun and Kobeni Department of HG region and the first with respect to Tintane department in the same region and Nouakchott, the capital city of Mauritania. It demonstrates that P. falciparum populations, at leat in Kobeni and Aïon, had maintained a high level of polymorphism in the msp-1 block 2 region. Studies using a larger number of blood samples collected from different geographic areas in Mauritania are required not only to determine the nationwide parasite heterogeneity and detailed malaria epidemiology but also to implement malarial control programmes in this neglected malaria country.
Authors’ contributions
MSOAS conceived of the study, carried out molecular study and performed statistical analysis; MN, BF, OG conceived and supervised molecular analyses and participated in the paper drafting; KML, OAM, carried out the microscopic analysis and participated in statistical analyses; HB, LK, OF, AOMSB conceived of the study, participated in its design and helped to draft and critically analysed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.