Background
Chronic kidney diseases (CKD) represent a growing public health problem
1
. Only few patients will experienced rapid renal function decline
2
and fewer will reach end stage renal disease
3
. Prediction of renal function outcome is a critical issue. Predictive factors include arterial hypertension, proteinuria and baseline renal function. In addition, interstitial fibrosis closely correlates to renal function and long-term prognosis
4
but in most patients, renal histology assessment is not performed. We interested in renal arterial resistive index (RI) because it can be measured not invasively by Doppler analysis of intrarenal arterial blood flow velocities and because its prognosis value has been proven in various clinical settings. These include the therapeutic management of renal artery stenosis
5
6
. During renal transplantation, increase in RI early after surgery is a marker of tubular necrosis
7
and, later on, is predictive of long-term graft dysfunction
8
.
However, the clinical interest of RI in the course of CKD is still unclear. Twenty years ago, Platt et al. showed that RI was significantly higher in nephropathies with tubulo-interstitial and/or vascular injury than in isolated glomerulopathies. Later on, four studies analyzed the correlation between RI and histological changes associated with the progression of CKD
9
10
11
12
. However, several points make these results questionable. First of all, pathological criteria were not clearly defined in two of these studies
10
11
. Moreover, although authors agreed that RI increased with tubulo-interstitial injury, three studies
10
11
12
did not distinguish chronic lesions, such as tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis, from interstitial oedema and cellular infiltration, which may result from acute injury. Three studies tested the correlation between RI and glomerulosclerosis and found conflicting results
9
10
12
. Only two groups examined simultaneously the association of RI with various lesions associated with CKD, i.e. tubulo-interstitial, glomerular and vascular lesions. Whereas the first study showed an association of RI with arteriosclerosis, but not with arteriolosclerosis
10
, the most recent one found that vascular lesions were globally associated with RI without distinction between arteriolar and arterial lesions
9
. Furthermore, the most accurate threshold of RI in clinical practice is still debated
12
13
. In parallel, several studies reported the correlation of RI with renal outcome in CKD
9
11
13
14
15
16
17
.
Despite these encouraging results, renal Doppler remains underemployed for the management of CKD in clinical practice. We conducted a prospective study in patients who underwent renal biopsy for diagnosis of CKD. Our primary goal was to assess the association between pathological lesions and RI. The second objective was to determine the relation of RI with renal function outcome. The last purpose was to establish the most relevant threshold of RI in clinical practice.
Methods
Ethics statement
The study was approved by the ethic committee CPP Ile-de France 5 and written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
Patients
We carried out a prospective study from October 2006 to November 2007 in 58 consecutive patients referred to the Nephrology department of the Tenon Hospital in Paris, France, who underwent a diagnosis renal biopsy. Inclusion criteria were the following: i) existence of a chronic kidney disease according to the KDOQI definition
18
, i.e. estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) < 60 mL/min/ 1.73 m2 and/or albuminuria ii) presence of at least 5 glomeruli on the biopsy sample, iii) renal US Doppler performed within two days before renal biopsy with a standardized measurement of RI. Patients were excluded from the study if they had renal artery stenosis, acute cardiac failure or hepato-renal syndrome.
Clinical and biological data
Clinical (age, sex, treatments and blood pressure) and biological data (serum creatinine, eGFR according to the modified MDRD formula and proteinuria/creatininuria ratio) were collected prospectively at inclusion. Biochemical parameters were all measured in the biochemistry laboratory of the hospital.
MDRD eGFR at 6, 12 and 18 months after renal biopsy was collected in 46 (79%), 43 (74%) and 35 (60%) patients, respectively. In cohort studies, slope of eGFR decline is less than -5 mL/min/ 1.73 m2 in the majority of CKD patients
2
19
20
21
22
23
. In order to be close to clinical practice, we chose to define renal function decline as a decrease in eGFR of at least 5 mL/min/ 1.73 m2/year from baseline or need for chronic renal replacement therapy (RRT).
Ultrasonographic doppler examination
US Doppler examination was performed in a standardized fashion by one of the two well-trained ultrasonographers selected for the study, in fasted patients. A SIEMENS ELEGRA SS device and a 3.5 MHz probe were used. For each patient, the maximal length of both kidneys was measured and added to obtain combined renal length. Arterial velocity signals were obtained from segmental or interlobar arteries in one kidney. Three records were performed at superior, medium and inferior poles. RI was calculated according to the Pourcelot’s formula: [(peak systolic velocity- end diastolic velocity)/ peak systolic velocity]. The mean of the three poles measures was used as the reference value of RI for each patient. In 15 patients, RI was measured in both kidneys with a Pearson’s correlation coefficient > 0.99.
Histological examination
For each patient, histological analysis was performed by a unique senior pathologist who was unaware of US Doppler results. Light microscopy examination was performed on samples stained by H & E, PAS, Jones and Masson’s trichrome. The whole cortex was analyzed on eight serial sections of each biopsy under 25 to 400 × magnification.
Interstitial fibrosis was assessed visually as the percentage of fibrotic interstitial cortical tissue visible on Masson’s stain by 5%-stages
24
. Glomerulosclerosis was defined as the percentage of totally sclerotic glomeruli. Arteriolosclerosis was defined as the presence of hyaline deposits in the wall of at least one preglomerular arteriole (Figure 1A). Absence of arteriolosclerosis was asserted when none of the eight sections display hyaline deposits. Arteriosclerosis was defined as a thickening of the intima of at least one artery. Patients were classified in three groups according to the maximal intima thickness visible on the biopsy sample (Figure 1B): i) absence of arteriosclerosis: normal intima thickness, ii) moderate arteriosclerosis: thickening of intima with an intima/media ratio < 1, iii) severe arteriosclerosis: thickening of intima with an intima/media ratio ≥ 1.
<p>Figure 1</p>Vascular lesions analyzed on renal biopsy (optic microscopy, Masson’s trichromic staining)
Vascular lesions analyzed on renal biopsy (optic microscopy, Masson’s trichromic staining).A: Arteriolosclerosis was defined as the presence of hyaline deposits (arrow) in the wall of at least one arteriole. B: Arteriosclerosis was defined as a thickening of intima. Maximal intima thickness visible on the sample biopsy was measured (double arrow). Here, intima/media ratio was superior to 1, which corresponds to severe arteriosclerosis.
![]()
Statistical analysis
Number and percentage of patients, median and minimum-maximum values are provided for qualitative and quantitative values respectively. Linear relationship of RI with other variables was tested with Pearson’s correlation test. Analysis of parameters associated with RI and renal function decline were compared with Chi-square and Mann–Whitney tests respectively for qualitative and quantitative variables. Kaplan Meier analysis was realized to determine renal survival according to RI value using the log-rank test. In order to determine independent parameters associated with RI or renal function decline, we performed a multiple linear or logistic regression, respectively, including variables with p < 0.20 in univariate analysis.
Statistical analysis was performed using http://marne.u707.jussieu.fr/biostatgv/ website, GraphPad Prism 5.0 and StatView 5.0 softwares. A two-tailed p value < 0.05 was considered to be significant.
Results
Characteristics of patients
Fifty-eight patients were enrolled in the study according to the inclusion criteria. Their characteristics are summarized in Table 1. They were predominantly male (68.9%). Their median age was 49 years [23–89]. Their median eGFR and proteinuria/creatininuria ratio were respectively 59 mL/min/ 1.73 m2 [5–130] and 245 mg/mmol [7–2000]. Forty seven (81%) patients presented glomerular nephropathy. On biopsy, median sclerotic glomeruli and interstitial fibrosis percentage were respectively 13% [0–96] and 10% [0–90]. The presence of arteriolosclerosis or arteriosclerosis could not be studied in 5 and 12 patients, respectively, because of the absence of visible arteriole or artery on biopsy sample. Hyaline arterial deposits were observed on 25 of the 53 biopsies with visible arteriolar sections (47.2%). Arteriosclerosis was observed in 21 of the 46 patients (45.6%) for whom at least one artery was present on the biopsy. Eight (17.3%) patients had severe arteriosclerosis with an intima/media ratio ≥ 1 (Table 1). Median RI was 0.62 [0.31 – 1.0].
<p>Table 1</p>
Characteristics of patients at baseline
Number of patients
58 (100%)
Age
49 [23–89]
Male
49 (68.9%)
Blood pressure (mmHg)
Systolic
130 (88–181)
Diastolic
78 (59–115)
Pulse pressure
50 (28–80)
Renal function
Serum creatinine (μmol/L)
124 (54–906)
eGFR (ml/min/1,73m
2
)
59 (5–130)
Proteinuria/creatininuria(mg/mmol)
245 (7–2000)
Antihypertensive treatments
No antihypertensive drug
27 (46.5%)
1 antihypertensive drug
11 (19%)
2 antihypertensive drugs
9 (15.5%)
≥ 3 antihypertensive drugs
11 (19%)
RAS blockers
23 (39.6%)
Renal biopsy
% sclerotic glomeruli
13 (0–96)
% interstitial fibrosis
10 (0–90)
Vascular lesions
34/51 (66.7%)
Arteriolar hyaline deposits
25/53 (47.2%)
Intima/media ratio
Normal
25 (54.4%)
< 1
13 (28.3%)
≥ 1
8 (17.3%)
Diagnosis
FSGN/HIVAN
9 (15.5%)
IgA nephropathy
11 (19%)
Membranous nephropathy
7 (12.1%)
Minimal change disease
3 (5.2%)
Lupus
3 (5.2%)
Vascularitis
3 (5.2%)
Membranous proliferative nephritis
2 (3.4%)
Diabetes
2 (3.4%)
Amyloidosis
2 (3.4%)
Other glomerulonephritis
5 (8.6%)
Acute tubulo-interstitial nephritis
3 (1.7%)
Chronic tubulo-interstitial nephritis
2 (3.4%)
Vascular nephropathy
2 (3.4%)
Other
4 (6.9%)
Renal arterial resistive index
0.62 (0.31-1.00)
Clinical and biological parameters associated with renal arterial resistive index
We found a positive correlation between RI and age (r = 0.435, p = 0.0063), pulse pressure (r = 0.303, p = 0.022) which are both associated with elevated arterial stiffness. Furthermore, RI was inversely correlated with baseline eGFR (r = −0.402, p = 0.0018) and to a lesser extent with combined renal length (r = −0.275, p = 0.038). In a multiple linear regression analysis including age, baseline eGFR, pulse pressure and combined renal length, only age (p = 0.0052) and baseline eGFR (p = 0.015) were independently associated with RI. We did not find any significant correlation of RI with proteinuria/creatininuria ratio (r = 0.141, p = 0.29), systolic (r = 0.080, p = 0.55) and diastolic blood pressure (r = −0.169, p = 0.21). RI was not different between patients who received an antihypertensive treatment and those who did not (p = 0.89). In the same way, RI did not differ between patients treated with renin angiotensin system (RAS) blockers (p = 0.65) and those who were not. RI was not influenced by the number of antihypertensive drugs prescribed (p = 0.87).
Histological parameters associated with renal arterial resistive index
RI was not different whether hyaline deposits were present or not (0.62 [0.31-1.00] vs 0.63 [0.50-0.71], p = 0.99) (Figure 2A). RI value was similar in patients with normal intima or moderate intima thickening (intima/media ratio < 1) (0.62 [0.52-0.83] vs 0.60 [0.31-0.69], p = 0.71). In contrast, patients with severe arteriosclerosis (intima/media ratio ≥ 1) had a significantly higher RI than those with no or moderate arteriosclerosis (0.73 [0.56-1.00] vs 0.61 [0.31-0.83], p = 0.032) (Figure 2B). No association was found between RI value and glomerulosclerosis. RI tended to increase with the percentage of interstitial fibrosis (n = 58, r = 0.222, p = 0.10) and was significantly higher when interstitial fibrosis exceeded 20% (0.67 [0.55-1.00] vs 0.61 [0.31- 0.83], p = 0.014) (Figure 2C). Finally, patients with isolated glomerular involvement had significant lower RI than those with interstitial fibrosis > 5% and/or vascular lesions (hyaline arterial deposits and/or intima thickening) (0.60 [0.47-0.64] vs 0.64 [0.31-1.00], p = 0.05).
<p>Figure 2</p>Association of RI with histological parameters
Association of RI with histological parameters. Boxes show the first and third quartiles, with the median as a thick line. Whiskers extend to minimum and maximum values. A: RI according to arteriolosclerosis, defined as the presence of hyaline deposits in the wall of at least one preglomerular arteriole. B: RI according to maximal intima thickness (moderate arteriosclerosis was defined as a thickening of intima with intima/media ratio < 1 and severe arteriosclerosis as an intima/media ratio ≥ 1). * p<0.05 versus normal and intima/media<1. C: RI according to interstitial fibrosis. * p<0.05 versus interstitial fibrosis<20%.
![]()
Association of renal arterial resistive index with renal function outcome
Renal function outcome was assessed at 18 months in 35 (60%) patients (Table 2). Among them, 13 (37%) patients experienced renal function decline. Seven patients had a decrease in eGFR of at least 5 mL/min/1.73 m2/year and 6 needed chronic RRT. Their RI was significantly higher than RI of patients with stable or improved renal function (0.69 [0.63-1.00] vs 0.61 [0.31-0.70], p = 0.0023) (Table 2). In univariate analysis, other factors associated with renal function decline at 18 months were: age (p = 0.0035), baseline eGFR (p = 0.052) and proteinuria/creatininuria ratio (p = 0.049) (Table 2). Baseline RI ≥ 0.65 (p = 0.0075) and age (p = 0.037) were the only independent factors associated with renal function decline at 18 months identified by multiple logistic regression (Table 3).
<p>Table 2</p>
Univariate analysis of parameters associated with renal function decline at 18 months (defined as a decrease in eGFR of at least 5 mL/min/ 1.73 m
2
/year or need for RRT) (Mann–Whitney and Fisher’s exact tests)
No decline
Decline
p
Number (%) of patients
22 (63%)
13 (37%)
Age (years)
38 (23–68)
55 (24–79)
0.0035
Baseline eGFR (mL/min/1.73m
2
)
65 (17–108)
12 (4–65)
0.052
eGFR(mL/min/1.73m
2
) at 18 months
69 (24–123)
8 (5–70)
0.000015
SBP (mmHg)
127 (98–160)
129 (98–163)
0.30
DBP (mmHg)
77 (62–91)
70 (59–96)
0.89
Proteinuria/creatininuria (mg/mmol)
96 (7–1216)
492 (69–1742)
0.049
% sclerotic glomeruli
16 (0–71)
4 (0–80)
0.88
% interstitial fibrosis
18 (0–80)
18 (0–90)
0.76
RI
0.61 (0.31-0.70)
0.69 (0.63-1.00)
0.0023
Number (%) of patients with RI ≥ 0.65
4 (18%)
10 (77%)
0.0011
<p>Table 3</p>
Multivariate analysis of parameters associated with renal function decline at 18 months (defined as a decrease in eGFR of at least 5 mL/min/ 1.73 m
2
/year or need for RRT) (logistic regression, n=35 patients)
OR
95% CI
P
Proteinuria/creatininuria (mg/mmol)
1.001
0.998-1.003
0.56
Baseline eGFR (mL/min/1.73m
2
)
0.977
0.936-1.021
0.30
Age (years)
1.079
0.996-1.169
0.062
RI ≥ 0.65
7.751
1.045-57.479
0.045
OR
95% CI
P
Age (years)
1.078
1.004-1.158
0.037
RI ≥ 0.65
13.04
1.984-85.727
0.0075
Which RI threshold should be used in clinical practice?
In order to define the most accurate threshold, we draw receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves (Figure 3). According to the ROC curves analysis, 0.65 threshold was the most discriminant for renal function decline at 18 months, interstitial fibrosis exceeding 20% and severe arteriosclerosis. Analysis of renal survival using Kaplan-Meier curves confirmed that patients with baseline RI ≥ 0.65 had a poorer renal outcome than those with baseline RI < 0.65 (p = 0.0005, Log-Rank test) (Figure 4). Sensitivity, specificity, predictive positive and predictive negative values of RI ≥ 0.65 for renal function decline at 18 months were respectively 77%, 86%, 71% and 82%.
<p>Figure 3</p>Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for RI to discriminate
Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for RI to discriminate.A: renal function decline at 18 months (AUC = 0.809, p = 0.0002). B: interstitial fibrosis > 20% (AUC = 0.690, p = 0.037). C: severe arteriosclerosis (AUC = 0.740, p = 0.039).
![]()
<p>Figure 4</p>Kaplan Meier curves of renal survival according to baseline RI. Renal function decline is defined as decrease in eGFR of at least 5mL/min/1.73m2/year or need for RRT
Kaplan Meier curves of renal survival according to baseline RI. Renal function decline is defined as decrease in eGFR of at least 5mL/min/1.73m2/year or need for RRT. Plain line represents patients with RI < 0.65 and dotted line those with RI ≥ 0.65; p = 0.0005,
log-rank test.
![]()
Discussion
The present study shows that initial measurement of RI in patients with various nephropathies at time of renal biopsy is clinically relevant for several reasons. We show that RI is associated with renal function and pulse pressure, a surrogate marker of arterial stiffness. More importantly, RI is associated with severe interstitial fibrosis and arteriosclerosis and eGFR decline. Previous studies reported either the association of RI with interstitial fibrosis, tubulo-interstitial lesions
9
10
11
12
25
, or vascular lesions
9
10
11
or renal outcome in CKD
9
11
13
15
16
. To our knowledge, none of these studies simultaneously evaluated the association of RI with the main chronic renal histological lesions and with renal function outcome. Furthermore, the most relevant threshold of RI for clinical practice was still debated. Here, the cut-off value of 0.65 was the most discriminant for severe arteriosclerosis, extended fibrosis and renal function decline.
In this study, we analyzed the association of RI with pathological changes and renal function outcome in an unselected population of 58 patients with various nephropathies and renal function alterations. In order to be closer to clinical practice, our inclusion criteria differ from other studies which were done in specific renal diseases
12
25
. Our results emphasize the general predictive value of RI in CKD patients independently of the type of nephropathy. Secondly, only well-defined chronic renal lesions as interstitial fibrosis, percentage of sclerotic glomeruli, arteriosclerosis lesions were taken into account in our study. These criteria differ from previous studies which used combined scores as tubulo-interstitial injury or interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy, which could reflect acute kidney injury
9
10
11
12
. Despite a relative small population of CKD patients, we found a significant association of RI with severe renal lesions and renal function decline, consistently with previous studies
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
20
.
As previous authors, we found a positive correlation between RI and age
10
26
27
28
29
and in a lesser extent with pulse pressure
26
30
31
32
33
. Prior studies reported an association between RI and other markers of arterial stiffness as pulse wave velocity
31
34
and ankle-brachial blood pressure index
35
. In our study, RI was not associated with systolic nor with diastolic blood pressure despite its relationship with pulse pressure. This suggests that the elevation of RI rather reflects the vascular consequences of hypertension than hypertension itself. An alternative explanation is the lack of power of our study. Nevertheless, this result was demonstrated by previous authors who showed that RI is a marker of target organ damage in essential hypertension
30
32
34
36
37
as left ventricular hypertrophy, carotid and coronary atherosclerosis. Other studies demonstrated that high RI was also associated with systemic atherosclerosis in diabetic patients
31
38
and renal transplant recipients
35
. Moreover, Pearce et al. recently showed that elevated renal RI is predictive of cardiovascular events in the elderly
39
.
The elevation of RI with severe arteriosclerosis may account for its association with cardiovascular risk. As previous authors
9
25
, we actually found an association between RI and renal arteriosclerosis. It is interesting to note that only patients with severe intima thickening exhibited high RI. Nor hyaline arteriolar deposits nor moderate intima thickening were associated with increased RI. This could be due to the lack of power of our study. Nevertheless, it could also suggest that the presence of moderate vascular lesions is not sufficient to induce an elevation of RI and that these alterations must be important enough to reduce artery lumen, raise arterial stiffness and vascular resistance, and consequently generate an increase in RI. Overall, these findings suggest that high RI reflects severe renal arteriosclerosis and maybe systemic arteriosclerosis.
Our study also questioned the correlation of RI with renal fibrosis. We did not find any relationship between RI and glomerulosclerosis. Moreover, RI was significantly lower in case of isolated glomerular involvement, i.e. without any vascular and/or tubulo-interstitial damage. This result corroborates previous findings of Platt et al.
25
. Only one among three previous studies found a significant association between glomerulosclerosis and RI
10
. This correlation was weak in a second study
12
and not significant in a multivariate analysis in the third one
9
. Altogether, these findings suggest that glomerulosclerosis does not influence the value of RI.
On the other hand, as other authors, we found an association between RI value and the extension of interstitial fibrosis
9
11
12
25
and the severity of renal impairment
13
26
40
41
42
43
44
. Median percentage of interstitial fibrosis was six fold higher in patients with RI exceeding 0.65. As arteriosclerosis, interstitial fibrosis appears as an important determinant of RI. Three hypotheses can be drawn about the physiopathological mechanisms involved in elevation of RI with the progression of CKD: i) decrease in arterial compliance and increase in vascular resistance because of renal arteriosclerosis, ii) elevation of pressure exerted by interstitial fibrosis on adjacent vessels, iii) vasoconstriction secondary to the hypoxia induced by the previous phenomena and by the loss of capillaries associated with renal fibrosis. These mechanisms are probably combined and our results do not allow us to precise which one contributes the most to the elevation of RI.
In the second part of our study, we found that high RI was independently associated with accelerated renal function decline. Sugiura et al.
13
reported similar result in a larger cohort of 311 CKD patients followed-up for two years. Such results were also found by other authors in CKD
11
14
15
16
17
, essential hypertension
17
and renal transplantation
8
45
. Our results extend previous findings to a population of patients with various nephropathies. The concomitant association of RI with interstitial fibrosis and arteriosclerosis which are known to be major determinants of the progression of CKD
4
may explain its prognosis value.
Finally, we attempted to define the most relevant threshold of RI in clinical practice. Consistently with the first findings of Sugiura et al.
12
, we found that 0.65 was the most accurate threshold to detect extent interstitial fibrosis, but also severe arteriosclerosis. Nevertheless, more recently, Sugiura et al. suggested that 0.70 threshold was better than 0.65 cut-off to predict renal function decline
13
. In contrast, we found by ROC curves analysis that RI ≥ 0.65 has the best sensitivity (77%) and specificity (86%) to discriminate renal function decline. This discrepancy may be explained by the different definitions of renal function decline used in the two studies. Using the criteria of at least 10 mL/min/ 1.73 m2/year, Sugiura et al. may have selected more severe patients. In cohort studies, mean slope of eGFR decline is less than 5 mL/min/ 1.73 m2 in most CKD patients
2
19
20
21
22
23
. A decrease of 5 mL/min/ 1.73 m2/year appears to be closer to clinical practice and more helpful to detect a larger of number patients at high risk of accelerated CKD progression.
Our study has several limits. We mostly included glomerulonephritis and few vascular and tubulo-interstitial diseases. Because of the weak proportion of chronic vascular and tubulo-interstitial diseases, we can wonder whether our results could apply to those nephropathies. Nevertheless, several previous studies found an association between high RI and poor renal outcome in essential hypertension and chronic tubulo-interstitial nephropathies
13
14
17
34
37
. The main limit of our study is the non exhaustive collection of renal function data. However, our results corroborate those of several previous studies
9
11
13
15
16
.